The same apart from being different models with vastly different mileage and most likely running different fuel, with further long list of minor differences
How many dyno runs was your car taken through to "optimise for each car"?
Ultimately, dynos are nowhere near +/-2-3% precision you're looking at at your graphs, especially when not done back to back. It is also not a massive problem as for sure both cars make very decent power outputs, which is probably what both of you wanted. Could these same cars make more power if mapped differently - probably yes, but you'd probably also not want it due to potential damage to the drivetrain.
One degree of ignition advance at 6,000-7,000 rpm most likely means more than difference between the pieces of metal you were discussing above, yet there is on average no appetite to consider these matters here.
Hopefully to make it clear - I have no interest in having any confrontation here and was initially only addressing the part of considerations regarding "this piece of kit may make more power and that piece of kit may make more torque"